Discover the 17 Most Valuable Jefferson Nickels You Could Own!: Jefferson Nickels have been in circulation since 1938, and while most of them are worth their face value, certain rare editions can be incredibly valuable.
Whether you’re a coin collector or just checking your spare change, understanding which Jefferson Nickels to look for can help you discover coins worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. In this guide, we’ll explore the 17 most valuable Jefferson Nickels and what makes them so special.
Overview Table
| Jefferson Nickel | Estimated Value |
| 1939-D Double Monticello | $500+ |
| 1942-P War Nickel (35% Silver) | $100+ |
| 1950-D Jefferson Nickel | $15 – $1,000 |
| 1939-S Jefferson Nickel | $50 – $150 |
| 1949-D Jefferson Nickel | $40 – $200 |
17 Most Valuable Jefferson Nickels
- 1939-D Double Monticello Nickel
This coin has a notable error where Monticello is doubled on the reverse. In mint condition, this rarity can fetch over $500. - 1942-P War Nickel (35% Silver)
Due to metal shortages during WWII, this coin contains 35% silver, making it valuable. A high-grade example can be worth more than $100. - 1950-D Jefferson Nickel
With one of the lowest mintages in the series, this coin can be worth between $15 and $1,000 depending on its condition. - 1939-S Jefferson Nickel
Another rare early issue, this coin is sought after by collectors and can range in value from $50 to $150. - 1949-D Jefferson Nickel
Known for its scarcity, the 1949-D Nickel can sell for $40 to $200 in excellent condition. - 1943-P War Nickel
Also made from 35% silver, this war nickel can be worth around $50 or more in top condition. - 1964 SMS (Special Mint Set) Jefferson Nickel
This rare coin was produced as part of an experimental minting process, and only a few exist. It can be worth thousands in pristine condition. - 1954-S Jefferson Nickel
Coins from the San Francisco Mint are rarer, and a well-preserved 1954-S can be worth between $30 and $100. - 1955 Jefferson Nickel (Proof)
The proof version of this coin is valuable to collectors, with some fetching up to $150. - 1945-P War Nickel
Another 35% silver war nickel, this coin can be worth $20 to $50 based on its condition. - 1938-D Jefferson Nickel
As one of the first Jefferson Nickels produced, this coin has historical value and can sell for $30 to $150 depending on its condition. - 1938-S Jefferson Nickel
Another early issue, it’s highly valued by collectors and can fetch over $100 in higher grades. - 1940-D Jefferson Nickel
Known for its scarcity in good condition, this coin can sell for $20 to $100. - 1944-D War Nickel
Produced during WWII, this nickel’s silver content and rarity make it valuable, with mint-condition coins selling for over $50. - 1953-S Jefferson Nickel
Coins from this year and mint can be worth $30 to $150, depending on their condition. - 1946-S Jefferson Nickel
Though more common than some, this coin is still valuable in mint state and can be worth $40 to $100. - 1941-D Jefferson Nickel
The 1941-D is another early issue that becomes more valuable in higher grades, with prices ranging from $20 to $80.
FAQs
What makes a Jefferson Nickel valuable?
The value of a Jefferson Nickel is determined by factors like rarity, mintmark, condition, and errors. Coins from low-mintage years or those with significant errors, like the Double Monticello, are especially valuable.
What makes the 1964 Jefferson Nickel rare?
The 1964 Jefferson Nickel is rare in its Special Mint Set (SMS) form, with only a few of these experimental coins known to exist, making them incredibly valuable.
What makes a buffalo nickel valuable?
Buffalo Nickels are valuable due to their age and detailed design. High-quality coins with well-preserved details or rare mintmarks, like those from the San Francisco Mint, can fetch high prices.
